In the past 18 years since 1990, ever since the success of opening up the economy to foreign direct investments hit infrastructure bottlenecks, the Malaysian economy has been undertaking mega projects to expand the infrastructure capacity of the local economy - that is, expanding its aggregate supply curve.
This expansion of the aggregate supply curve had proved so lucrative to the policy makers that even as a solution to the problem created by it in 1997-98, the solution remained additional expenditure on infrastructure. This "counter-cyclical fiscal stimulus" has proven itself so easy to propose and implement that many politicians and poorly-schooled economists may be tempted to imagine themselves to be brilliant economists.
Infrastructure projects are probably one of the easiest projects to implement (so long as one has the money) because there is no accountability to their economic or commercial viability.
So, since 1990, Malaysia's aggregate supply curve has been pushed further and further out to the right.
The idea of building more infrastructure facilities is to expand the productive capacity of the local economy so that there is more room for private-sector business investments to increase and in the process generate growth in the economy.
If private investments are unchanged and the aggregate demand curve stays the same, the sustained expansion of the aggregate supply curve means that operators of infrastructure facilities will lose money due to insufficient demand - and the only way to ensure profitability is to raise the prices high enough, and this is easy to do for monopolies. (Note Khazanah's strategy to turn around GLCs, as an example.)
In the meantime, having expanded the supply side, Malaysia undertook no extra effort to expand the aggregate damand for infrastructure. When the Japanese and others looked to China after the 1997-98 crisis, the local operating environment hardened further for domestic direct investment. The clamour for lucrative government contracts (on the supply side) led inadvertently to a government machinery that has become hostile to homegrown investments.
Easy money policy therefore led not to an increase in local direct investments in factories and plants for exports or businesses of entrepreneurs, but to an increase in the collateral assets for banks - namely, real estate and even financial assets. With this came the consumption boom - of cars and credit cards - which thought great for the local retail trade but is no good for the secondary sector of the economy - the real economy of producing things they can be sold to the world.
Malaysia needs to expand its aggregate demand curve, by encouraging direct investments, not only from foreigners but also from Malaysians themselves. Opportunnities must be created for investors to take risk and keep the fruit of their efforts rather than have rules and regulations that strangle confidence and the animal spirits and the long-term faith in the economy. To invest is to keep faith with the country.
The monetary policy is easy enough - interest rates are low enough and banks are very keen to lend. The fiscal policy has become so elongated that we may have to raise debt to finance it. But there is a need for policy and the government process and machinery to take an enlightened view of the workings of reality.
The current global financial meltdown shows that wealth as most people perceived it is a figment of their own personal imagination, while the richness lies in the openness of society out there - of the money that is yet to be made. Assets are nothing but relics of dead people that the living merely sit on.
The expansion of the aggregate demand curve by consumption is a drive in the wrond direction as the current financial meltdown also shows. There is a need to invest by putting resources to productive use, productive in the sense that we are continually extracting more and more out of the available resources for the benefit of society, rather than to feed the greed of individuals or the fancy of a group.
Let Malaysians BE ALLOWED TO invest in Malaysia and stake a claim in the future of their own homeland - rather than be over-run by billionaires and foreigners!
Thursday, October 30, 2008
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
How To Repair the Malaysian Economy
When the dust settles, what would we see?
An OECD paralysed, with a financial system staying barely afloat.
China may use the opportunity to refocus growth from foreign-owned export industries to local-owned domestic-oriented firms especially in major inland cities. There will be oppportunities for investors outside China to produce quality inputs for Chinese industries.
What will happen in the Malaysia economy? What must be done to repair the Malaysian economy?
The traditional Malaysian society and economy that we all have grown up in have been drastically changed - some would say destroyed.
We are no more Malays, Chinese, Indians and native Sarawakians and Sabahans.
Malaysia is now a mixture of billionaires, foreign workers, a whole bunch of speculators in shares and real estate, and consultants to government departments and GLCs.
We are all in for the quick gain. As opportunities for windfall gains evaporates as the oil money run out, we are all assassinating politicians for being empty handed.
First, beef up internal security to prepare for a spate of recession-induced crimes in the street.
Second, repartriate low-wage foreign workers. They are the ones that keep wages low and inhibit the use of technology in the economy - including construction.
Third, focus on investments - for exports to China. Malaysians should try to hire local professionals of all races. It is far better than attracting foreign investors to hire local professionals of all races.
Fourth, Malaysians should close ranks to work on putting together the fragmented economy (and the fragmented institutions). The divisive politics has destroyed the economy, and we do not need any 80-year olds to paddle us old-fashioned ideologies. For goodness' sake, we are in a globalised world - and what race are we talking about or are we really talking about power, monopoly, disgraceful wealth and opulence on the backs of those who toil.
Fifth, create a Third Force - the Liberals who care for the creation and spreading of economic opportunities throughout the whole society regardless of race or religion. We should take all key issues in Malaysia including the NEP-type and work out effective and transparent ways of balancing out wealth distribution, instead of the very crude old-fashioned quotas and licenses. There should be price-incentives to induce productivity gains and market-based wealth creation.
Sixth, sit down and do some proper political and economic analyses and publish them in peer-reviewed journals, even if of local origin. We have too much of foreign models using local data, and not enough original local thinking taking into account local conditions.
Seventh, we should take the Minister of Finance portfolio away from the PM and the DPM and give it back to the Minister of Finance. The PM should concentrate on national harmony and the DPM on internal security. The Minister of Finance on government spending and finance. The Central Bank on fighting inflation and financial speculation. Let the private sector a free hand to undertake investment. Remove politics from investment decisions.
Eighth, we have enough infrastructure to last another generation. We have expanded the aggregate supply curve. Let us work to use the infrastructure efficiently. Move the aggregate demand curve.
Ninth, reinstate the role of professionals in the economy. Remove politically-oreinted managers from public places.
Tenth, reinstate the role of markets in the economy with price movements doing the resource allocation. Let the people work, sweat, earn and keep.
An OECD paralysed, with a financial system staying barely afloat.
China may use the opportunity to refocus growth from foreign-owned export industries to local-owned domestic-oriented firms especially in major inland cities. There will be oppportunities for investors outside China to produce quality inputs for Chinese industries.
What will happen in the Malaysia economy? What must be done to repair the Malaysian economy?
The traditional Malaysian society and economy that we all have grown up in have been drastically changed - some would say destroyed.
We are no more Malays, Chinese, Indians and native Sarawakians and Sabahans.
Malaysia is now a mixture of billionaires, foreign workers, a whole bunch of speculators in shares and real estate, and consultants to government departments and GLCs.
We are all in for the quick gain. As opportunities for windfall gains evaporates as the oil money run out, we are all assassinating politicians for being empty handed.
First, beef up internal security to prepare for a spate of recession-induced crimes in the street.
Second, repartriate low-wage foreign workers. They are the ones that keep wages low and inhibit the use of technology in the economy - including construction.
Third, focus on investments - for exports to China. Malaysians should try to hire local professionals of all races. It is far better than attracting foreign investors to hire local professionals of all races.
Fourth, Malaysians should close ranks to work on putting together the fragmented economy (and the fragmented institutions). The divisive politics has destroyed the economy, and we do not need any 80-year olds to paddle us old-fashioned ideologies. For goodness' sake, we are in a globalised world - and what race are we talking about or are we really talking about power, monopoly, disgraceful wealth and opulence on the backs of those who toil.
Fifth, create a Third Force - the Liberals who care for the creation and spreading of economic opportunities throughout the whole society regardless of race or religion. We should take all key issues in Malaysia including the NEP-type and work out effective and transparent ways of balancing out wealth distribution, instead of the very crude old-fashioned quotas and licenses. There should be price-incentives to induce productivity gains and market-based wealth creation.
Sixth, sit down and do some proper political and economic analyses and publish them in peer-reviewed journals, even if of local origin. We have too much of foreign models using local data, and not enough original local thinking taking into account local conditions.
Seventh, we should take the Minister of Finance portfolio away from the PM and the DPM and give it back to the Minister of Finance. The PM should concentrate on national harmony and the DPM on internal security. The Minister of Finance on government spending and finance. The Central Bank on fighting inflation and financial speculation. Let the private sector a free hand to undertake investment. Remove politics from investment decisions.
Eighth, we have enough infrastructure to last another generation. We have expanded the aggregate supply curve. Let us work to use the infrastructure efficiently. Move the aggregate demand curve.
Ninth, reinstate the role of professionals in the economy. Remove politically-oreinted managers from public places.
Tenth, reinstate the role of markets in the economy with price movements doing the resource allocation. Let the people work, sweat, earn and keep.
Recession: Simple Analysis
Many people think that prices are symmetrical in their impact - when prices go up, people buy less; when prices fall, people buy more. So, if we raise prices and then lower them back to the same levels as before, things will be back to where they were before.
No quite right!
Say, when prices are doubled and people's nominal incomes are unchanged, they can only buy half the quantity of the things they used to buy.
When this happens, businesses will have only halve the usual sales and warehouses full of unsold goods. They may try to lower the prices but they will be making losses. Instead, they retrench staff to produce half the usual volume, if they were to simply write off their unsold goods.
By retrenching, they are creating the signs of a recession - the recession has already set when prices were raised.
If prices were then reduced to the same old level, people will buy what they used to buy - which is the amount they earned - but without the income lost by those who were unemployed.
After the fuel and food price hike, there should be no doubt that the recession is already set for the world.
No quite right!
Say, when prices are doubled and people's nominal incomes are unchanged, they can only buy half the quantity of the things they used to buy.
When this happens, businesses will have only halve the usual sales and warehouses full of unsold goods. They may try to lower the prices but they will be making losses. Instead, they retrench staff to produce half the usual volume, if they were to simply write off their unsold goods.
By retrenching, they are creating the signs of a recession - the recession has already set when prices were raised.
If prices were then reduced to the same old level, people will buy what they used to buy - which is the amount they earned - but without the income lost by those who were unemployed.
After the fuel and food price hike, there should be no doubt that the recession is already set for the world.
Reinstate the Gold Standard
Keynes came in after the 1903s Depression to argue with the simple market economists in the Treasury that letting the market find its bottom would not help because many people were hungry and had no money to create the demand needed by the market. This is, in essence, the General Theory or GT.
Keynes also reinstated the gold standard and created the IMF to help maintain the gold standard by providing the necessary liquidity to stabilise currencies.
The failure of the US financial system - what it looks like to be the world financial system as practiced by the West and imitated by the East - is the destruction of the gold standard in 1973 when Nixon removed the US dollar from it - which led Greenspan to abuse it with its unbridled expansion in the name of free market and global innovation.
But the free marketeers had failed to define market rules under which everyone should operate. Banks are left to innovate to their hearts' content. The referees were sleeping.
The solution to the global financial system is to go back to the gold standard, regulate money supply, control inflation - so that the real economy and people who really work can proceed to go about with their ordinary lives - working and consuming and waiting to die.
Keynes also reinstated the gold standard and created the IMF to help maintain the gold standard by providing the necessary liquidity to stabilise currencies.
The failure of the US financial system - what it looks like to be the world financial system as practiced by the West and imitated by the East - is the destruction of the gold standard in 1973 when Nixon removed the US dollar from it - which led Greenspan to abuse it with its unbridled expansion in the name of free market and global innovation.
But the free marketeers had failed to define market rules under which everyone should operate. Banks are left to innovate to their hearts' content. The referees were sleeping.
The solution to the global financial system is to go back to the gold standard, regulate money supply, control inflation - so that the real economy and people who really work can proceed to go about with their ordinary lives - working and consuming and waiting to die.
Central Banks Have Failed!
Risk managment tries to minimise the risk associated with a given situation, structure or paradigm.
Uncertainty is associated with the changing of situation, structure or paradigm.
Risk management is a cope-out that marginalises the need to deal with uncertainty.
A bank works on the assumption that it is as good as its collateral value - which is largely mortgages or mortgage-backed papers. The collateral value increases with bank lending, which means that there is no limit to loan expansion - until the borrowers are exhausted and couldn't pay.
In risk management, you work to ensure that the collateral really does exist, and that its current value is indeed what the market says.
When the situation changes as a result of the exhaustion by banks of their customers, the whole bank lending system collapses - and out of it comes uncertainty - as to what the next model will be.
There is no uncertainty where the banking system is going - down!
There is uncertainty as to what to replace the banking system - that is, what banking policy - and nobody has a clue - because nobody is thinking about it.
While individual banks undertake risk management, it is responsibility of the central bank to manage systemic risks.
Central banks around the world have failed.
Uncertainty is associated with the changing of situation, structure or paradigm.
Risk management is a cope-out that marginalises the need to deal with uncertainty.
A bank works on the assumption that it is as good as its collateral value - which is largely mortgages or mortgage-backed papers. The collateral value increases with bank lending, which means that there is no limit to loan expansion - until the borrowers are exhausted and couldn't pay.
In risk management, you work to ensure that the collateral really does exist, and that its current value is indeed what the market says.
When the situation changes as a result of the exhaustion by banks of their customers, the whole bank lending system collapses - and out of it comes uncertainty - as to what the next model will be.
There is no uncertainty where the banking system is going - down!
There is uncertainty as to what to replace the banking system - that is, what banking policy - and nobody has a clue - because nobody is thinking about it.
While individual banks undertake risk management, it is responsibility of the central bank to manage systemic risks.
Central banks around the world have failed.
Monday, October 27, 2008
Flat With the Nose Dipped
Chinks in the Malaysian economic armour?
We have had nearly thirty "good" years since 1980 spending the "oil" money and pretending to the great. The real chink is that the "oil" money is gone, and populist policy of subsidising food and fuel is being removed - in the midst of probably one of the greatest economic turmoils of the century. So much for timing. This implicates the whole generation of politicians who went along with the merry-go-round.
Financially, we took the hit in the 1997-1998 financial crisis, from which we have not recovered. Indeed, danger looms still in the financial industry which has been quite happy to lend to consumers to buy stocks, cars and houses and a good time. But I think that the downside is limited, given that the industry has been recapitalised. I do not mean that the financial industry will not take a hit again - it is likely to, but not to the magnitude as in 1997-98 or what we see in the US and the rest of the developed world which has been relying on financial services for a living.
Malaysia will also feel a similar effect from the credit crunch. The way the local stock market is mimicking the world markets being that the local economy has no real fundamentals on its own. It has similarly been floating on inflated real estate and the general "consumer'led" recovery of old. With the scare, property prices will deflate to its real value - which could be easily halved in some areas - and this will also remove the excuse for banks to lend without thinking.
Even if interest rates are not raised or credit rules tightened, banks may not be inclined to lend.
Without loan growth, the economy will easily be flat with the tip of its nose down - before it nosedives.
The real chink is in its loss of momentum - from an irrelevant economic structure.
The relevant structure is to refocus the economy on competing in the world market - not the generation of billionaires through mega projects.
We have had nearly thirty "good" years since 1980 spending the "oil" money and pretending to the great. The real chink is that the "oil" money is gone, and populist policy of subsidising food and fuel is being removed - in the midst of probably one of the greatest economic turmoils of the century. So much for timing. This implicates the whole generation of politicians who went along with the merry-go-round.
Financially, we took the hit in the 1997-1998 financial crisis, from which we have not recovered. Indeed, danger looms still in the financial industry which has been quite happy to lend to consumers to buy stocks, cars and houses and a good time. But I think that the downside is limited, given that the industry has been recapitalised. I do not mean that the financial industry will not take a hit again - it is likely to, but not to the magnitude as in 1997-98 or what we see in the US and the rest of the developed world which has been relying on financial services for a living.
Malaysia will also feel a similar effect from the credit crunch. The way the local stock market is mimicking the world markets being that the local economy has no real fundamentals on its own. It has similarly been floating on inflated real estate and the general "consumer'led" recovery of old. With the scare, property prices will deflate to its real value - which could be easily halved in some areas - and this will also remove the excuse for banks to lend without thinking.
Even if interest rates are not raised or credit rules tightened, banks may not be inclined to lend.
Without loan growth, the economy will easily be flat with the tip of its nose down - before it nosedives.
The real chink is in its loss of momentum - from an irrelevant economic structure.
The relevant structure is to refocus the economy on competing in the world market - not the generation of billionaires through mega projects.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Rescue, Excuse
You who are so new to the job, how come you are so quickly ill-advised about what to do with the economy?!
I hope you have thrown away the same fellows who had advised the Prime Minister previously to raise fuel prices by 41% and got our prices to double across the board - just because you do not want foreigners to enjoy the fuel subsidy. Look at the mess! Great idea, bad timing!
I really hope it is not the same fellows who had just advised you on using a RM5 billion loan from EPF to support shares in the market. You reckoned that the prices of shares that this investment company is going to buy will rise so much that when you sell them again you can make enough to repay EPF the RM5 billion plus interest. If so, you are rising and falling according to your own will, and not the will of the market!
I think the government should stop fiddling with the stock market. It is the easiest route to hell and you are leading the whole economy onto that fiery path.
Remember this: No easy money, no easy money! You fellas got to do some real work, rather than showing us tricks with smoke and mirrors! Worst, if you do not realise that this is happening.
Real work means translating learning into ideas so that the welfare of the ordinary people could be improved - not helping your rich friends not to become poor when they are burnt in the market.
Put a bit of competition into the tenders so that the margins can be reduced, and the work gets done properly.
Better still, let the markets be free so that good people can have the chance to do proper work to contribute to the economy.
We should let the economy sag a bit first to weed out the waste, and not be too keen to rescue, rescue. It's excuse, excuse!
I hope you have thrown away the same fellows who had advised the Prime Minister previously to raise fuel prices by 41% and got our prices to double across the board - just because you do not want foreigners to enjoy the fuel subsidy. Look at the mess! Great idea, bad timing!
I really hope it is not the same fellows who had just advised you on using a RM5 billion loan from EPF to support shares in the market. You reckoned that the prices of shares that this investment company is going to buy will rise so much that when you sell them again you can make enough to repay EPF the RM5 billion plus interest. If so, you are rising and falling according to your own will, and not the will of the market!
I think the government should stop fiddling with the stock market. It is the easiest route to hell and you are leading the whole economy onto that fiery path.
Remember this: No easy money, no easy money! You fellas got to do some real work, rather than showing us tricks with smoke and mirrors! Worst, if you do not realise that this is happening.
Real work means translating learning into ideas so that the welfare of the ordinary people could be improved - not helping your rich friends not to become poor when they are burnt in the market.
Put a bit of competition into the tenders so that the margins can be reduced, and the work gets done properly.
Better still, let the markets be free so that good people can have the chance to do proper work to contribute to the economy.
We should let the economy sag a bit first to weed out the waste, and not be too keen to rescue, rescue. It's excuse, excuse!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)