Thursday, December 11, 2008

Keynesian Irrelevance V: Distribution

Keynes didn't write much about the distribution of income and wealth.

But his heart was with the poor people. Poor people spend all that they have, because they do not have enough money. Their behaviour has a good stimulative effect on the economy that works through the multiplier. Keynes' General Theory can be seen as celebration of the poor people. The rich, with too much money, cannot spend all that they have and have to save some. It is the some of the money that is saved that causes the economy to get depressed.

The money that is left over after consumption is invested, either in cash, financial assets, real estate or businesses, or a combination of these.

As a result, the concept of the rate of return on investment is invented (way before Keynes was born). But according to Keynes, it is the relative rate of return that determines the type of investment.

Cash is held because it keeps its capital value (a dollar is always a dollar; a piece of gold is always a piece of gold).

Financial assets depend on the stock market - this is supposed to be akin to investing in businesses except that there is capital gains when everybody's hobby is to punt the market. (I am glad the stock market is down though not out, because this should force some people to do something tangible like working at a job.) The stock market is active only when there is a lot of excess liquidity, thanks in no small part to the efforts of greedy banking CEOs who want to cash out on their stock options.

Businesses are the best thing to be in because they mobilise resources - capital, people and ideas - to work for the specific purpose of serving society. If a business does not serve any purpose, it will die naturally. If it serves the common needs of people, it will survive for a long time but the margin is low and competition is intense (food stalls). If it serves the specialised needs of a few, then the volume is low, margin high, and it may still go on for a long time (Rolex).

Many years ago, to justify further studies to my father (I was interested in the Theory of Income Distribution at the time), I rephrased it as, "I want to study why people are poor." He replied, "No good. Study why people are rich."

Why are people poor? People are poor when they rely on their labour to do work. They get tired and they can get just enough for subsistence. When they are too young or too old, they become destitute.

Why are people rich? People are rich because they use non-labour assets to gain more non-labour assets. In simple English, they use money to make money. So, money is doing all the hard work, so that the rich people can enjoy their consumption at leisure (rather than eat to live like the poor people).

You find that all the things that we commonly associate the idea of an asset are all man-made objects that are pertinent mainly in urban society - including cash. Wealth, at the end of the day, is nothing but just man-made artefacts of value only to urbanites - valued only because commonly desired.

In a rural community, such as the kampung, you find that different things are deemed to be valuable - social ties, co-operation and the jungle. The basic things are provided by nature - the fish from the river, the fruits from the jungle. Because the environment is so user-friendly, rural folks do not worry too much. They take only what they need for the moment. They try to leave everything as natural as possible - because by keeping things natural the maintenance cost is the lowest, zero.

Wheresas in urban society, nothing is for free. Friendship is not free. So, urbanites must earn as much as they can when they are able, in order to save enough when they become unable as a result of age or health. The creation and accumulation of artificial man-made artefacts is the whole raison detre of urban existence - including even the type of education we pursue or wish our children pursue. Even the use of English in schools is argued on the basis of the need for survival in urban societies. In rural soceities, I suppose they are more concerned about preserving their own quaint little ways, endowed upon them by their foreparents.

But this does not mean that rural communities are perfect beings without envy. They may envy the wealth of the urbanites. That envy may be impressed upon them by would-be individuals who pretend to show them the way to immense pleasure without sweat (apart from golfing).

The path to wealth and prosperity and the removal of poverty in rural areas is to destroy rural societies and rural ways of life and the natural environment and transforming them into urban societies with their concrete blocks as shelters and space for all types of innovative human activities without the chance of placing their feet on the ground, in exchange for little pieces of paper called cash.

In this way, the Keynesian-type policy is used to transform society and redistribute wealth. Money newly printed on the basis of the budget deficit is therefore bestowed upon a select few in the hope of it being spread around but did not because of the inability to regenerate that wealth. So the multiplier effect of the wealth generating machinery failed to boot up.

Keynesian fiscal policy can be appealing on first encounter because it seems to be such common sense. However, on repeated usage and abusage, the fiscal policy has the nasty consequence of creating a ballooning budget deficit and an excess of liquidity that is at once inflationary at home and in terms of the constantly depreciating currency. If you are wondering why you feel poor while surrounding yourself with comfort blankets like financial assets and real estate, it is because of too much Keynesianism.

If our politicians claim to have made the country grown and become wealthy, ask them why the local currency has lost its libido and is always limpid. Where is the central bank?

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Keynesian Irrelevance IV: Employment

Keynes assumed a simple employment theory: that a 1% increase in output increases employment by 1%.

1. The reason that the economy must grow each year is more and more graduates and non-graduates are entering the job market and we must create jobs for them. If the labour force increases by 3% a year, the economy must by 3% a year to absorb the new labour.

How do we create jobs for our young people? By employing them.

Even if they are considered "unemployable," they can still be retrained for some simpler jobs. The government must spend money on programmes for our people to find their "calling." Germany has life-long education where some graduates are professional students. Whatever, it is good for the government to be engaged with the youngsters so that their skills can be depoyed into new areas of activity in a positive vein. The sin of the government is to ignore the youth.

Short courses and programmes can be designed to cater to their abilities and interests. The government should pay them subsistence allowance to encourage their training and re-training until they discover themselves. We have become too callous in our approach to our youth. I am sure many are suffering from cultural shock, once they turn away from the TV and into the real world.

Any government programme, of whatever kind (I could fall into the classic "Keynesian literal trap") for the youth is better than building roads that lead to nowhere.

If a road is built that employed illiterate foreign workers and guarantees profit to a man who has already made his million and that road leads to nowhere, I would rather pay money to a fresh secondary school or university graduate to study some course for 9 months or 18 months, with subsistence, so that the young person would have some confidence in a future for himself or herself in this country. The person may do drama or join a rock band or be a poet - and this is a road that leads to somewhere. And it is far better than digging holes and filling them up.

It may not be immediately obvious that the engaged youth is employed - but can be classified outside the labour force, so that being "unemployed" are those actively looking for a job.

2. It is always prejudiced to get industry to dictate to the government which sector should be "stimulated." It is not difficult to imagine that the over-grown and over-sized construction sector will continue to clamour for more money to pile up brick and mortar. This is no doubt driven by land owners who want to capitalise on their assets. But the government should ask final year students and fresh graduates what types of jobs they want to do - and the government should spend money to fund their projects. This may even be in the form of industrial training or in an oversea stint to do volunteer work to gain experience and new insights. This is far better than paying for the overseas trade and investment missions by old men and women who are already quite fed up with seeing the world.

3. I am constantly amazed by the artistic flair of our people. This group should be encouraged through competition which pays a decent prize - meaning sufficient for the winners to survive without earning an income for a year in rented rooms. It is the artists, the poets and the writers who help us as a society to embrace our circumstance and enjoy it rather than harping on how things might have been. (I think the Chinese are too clinical in their artistic pursuits, but they might still be able to make their own mark.)

4. I am fascinated by the infinite ability of individuals and communities to establish their own equilibrium way of life. The social culture is established by people forming their set of habits which they practice day after day. Too much has been pulled to the centre by the central government which is disruptive to traditional societies. This is because some brilliant PM is keen to set up a new town to call his own. It is far better for the common person that the central government decentralises its expenditures so that more is given to the outliers - as a means of creating jobs in areas with lower costs of living.

5. So much talk about ICT. Thanks to ICT, we can actually decentralise faster. It will be interesting if we can have a national IT network that reports news and views from all the little nooks and corners of the nation, to see how our distant cousins are doing at this precise moment at home, so to speak. I am reminded of an observation that the age of globalisation means that we know all about the US financial meltdown but not whether our neighbour is suffering from depression and needed help. We don't need Cyberjaya or MSC to do ICT.

6. Many Malaysians have come to accept a boring way of life. They want a stable job - so they get themselves stuck in the civil service in a boring job for life and end up doing a disservice to themselves and the nation. They want a prestigious job - and get stuck as a doctor in a clinic entertaining rich but miserable clients. They should sample a variety of jobs to see which one gives them the most happiness and just enough cash for their needs and even desires. I think the availability of a wide spectrum of jobs should enrich the job market as well as our culture and the lives of our people.

7. Conclusion

The government could embark on the following mega projects:

i.) The National Battle of the Lead Guitarists with Rock Bands (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

ii.) The National Battle of the Drummers with Rock Bands (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

iii.) The National Battle of the Stand-Up Comic Artists (RM500,000)-first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize:RM100,000

iv.) The National Battle of the Comic Book Artists (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize:RM100,000

v.) The National Battle of the Cartoonists (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

vi.) The National Battle of the Short Story Writers (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

vii.) The National Battle of the Novelists (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

viii.) The National Battle of the Poets (RM500,000)- first prize: RM250,000; second prize: RM150,000; third prize: RM100,000

ix.) The National Battle of the Short Film Makers (RM1,000,000)- first prize: RM500,000; second prize: RM300,000; third prize: RM200,000

The total prize money of these 9 mega projects is RM5 million.

If in two languages, RM10 million.

Promotion and related events at RM2 million each would cost RM18 million for one language and RM36 million for two languages.

The entire programme for two languages would cost only RM46 million a year. The programme can be repeated every year until the unemployment rate goes down to 2%.

Keynesian Irrelevance III: Economic Growth

Keynes never wrote about charting our own future. He was clever in inserting money into the economic system and described its volatility - but not growth.

But Keynes does demonstrate one thing - that the economy grows as fast as the new expenditure in the economy. If income Y is consumed to the amount of C, then the remainder is saved (Y-C) which if not invested (spent) will lead to a fall in income. But if the investment is only (Y-C), you have no growth - you have stagnation. So, there must be new investment.

New investment comes from optimism which is derived from confidence - the willingness to stake one's future in the soil under one's feet. After all, if you have to invest more you have saved, you have to borrow and you are basically relying on the stream of future incomes.

It takes a lot to try to pay back loans. You can ask all those poor people who have to run away from the loan sharks. I did loan recovery once; and I can tell you that I was merciless.

To pay back loans, you must believe in the system in which you live. You must really love it in order not to run away when unpaid loans. You want to pay back because you want to the system works, you want your society to be vibrant, to be happy to contribute and pay back.

The Malaysian system has a way of mistreating its people and turn perfectly good citizens into migrants.

How do we build our own future?

1. Educate our people well. If they cannot find jobs at home, they can find jobs abroad. This is OK; we just have to learn to calculate GNP - not GDP.

2. Let us be creative. We should first learn to say exactly the opposite what the authorities are telling us, so that when we all cool down, we can come to a compromise - which we hope will be the middle path.

3. Let us build our own future. Our future is not the one that is being imprinted in our minds by the media. Our future is the one that we feel most happy being. I think all Malaysians love to be truly Malaysians. You can't find Malaysians in Malaysia - you find them abroad in strange places, when we are all out of our own comfort zone. Which really means that Malaysians are really at home in their own homes, during which we just choose to be difficult and idiosyncratic. Malaysians may just be more eccentric than the English.

4. Let us find a way of weaving our various cultural elements into a colourful fabric. I disagree in pushing our economy too fast, as what we have done in the past two decades - creating friction in the process. We should take our own pace - because our social fabric is delicate. We should take time to understand what we are doing. If we are trying to build something new, I do not think we have the experts in our midst - because if really new, no one really has that experience or knowledge before. We only have our own instincts to go by. Once we feel it is right, we have found our home - in our own soil.

5. Let us not look for that clever person to solve all our problems - we do not want a Hitler, Stalin or Mao. We should look to ourselves and our neighbours and our neighbourhoods for ideas and inspirations and grow indigeneous ideas. We should build stable and secure localised networks.

6. Why should we fear when we have resources. We should work to preserve our natural endowments and increase our own satisfactions.

I was once asked by my professor in university abroad: " Why is it that most of knowledge is created in the northern hemisphere and so little in the tropics?"

Answer: "I do not know about knowledge, but I agree there is a lot of mental activity. It is so dark and cold here, whereas in the tropics, there is constant sunshine and fair weather that one is often inclined to just relax and enjoy life."

I think that remark still rings true.

In other words - as my mother would say - grow, my child, but not too fast.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Keynesian Irrelevance II: Multiplier (or Investment)

It is important to recognise the irrelevance of Keynes in today's world because, if we do not, then we will end with with impotent policies of a Keynesian nature. Let me elaborate.

To any slight economic downturn or depression, all of us have "pump-priming" as a policy response at the tip of our tongues - from ministers to bankers and newspapers, and even men and women in the street. At the back of their minds, they are encouraged by their appreciation of the beauty of the concept called "the multiplier."

Mathematically, "the multiplier" is nothing more than just a simple series. If you first have the item "(1-c)Y", followed by (1-c)(1-c)Y, and (1-c)(1-c)(1-c)Y, till infinity, then you can collapse the whole series neatly into a sum of "1/(1-c)Y." So, if c=0.8, then the multilpier is 5.

This multiplier was first put forward by Richard Kahn, a Cambridge professor, as some sort of a theory of employment and appended by Keynes to his Theory of Money and Interest to become the General Theory of Money, Interest and Employment.

If c is consumption out of income Y, then (1-c)Y is saved. This is a no brainer.

Now, the first assumption is that the savings of (1-c)Y is fully invested. There is no necessity of that. In an economic recession like today, may be a fraction or none of (1-c)Y is invested. So, if the government were to pump in a stimulus package G, then cG will lead to consumption and the remaining (1-c)G may be saved in the banks or leaked abroad.

When there is leakage out of the system, there is a need to put more and more in. So G1 will be followed by G2 and G3 and so on. This series of stimulus package has been going on for years in Malaysia. The multiplier just does not get cranked up.

Why?

There are two factors:
(1) type of investment
(2) confidence.

Type of Investment

Keynes never discussed the type of investment in any detail; it would seem he even brushed it off as "employing men to dig holes in the roads and fill them up again." Unfortunately, this little off-handed remark - as a result of trying to persuade the Treasury at the time to spend money - has been used much too common by politicians today to justify dubious projects at the slightest hint of an economic slowdown.

You may think that is good - in keeping the economic growth rate up; but it also has the damaging effect of prolonging its much needed adjustment.

This is what we are seeing in Malaysia. We have been propping up the construction sector that has the effect of creating jobs of illiterate foreign workers, while we have forgotten to create jobs for the young graduated we have generated in our universities. I think there is as much as problem of a mismatch in the education sector where supply has been expanded without the attendant increase in demand for graduates.

There is a need to expand the educated sector of the economy so that we can keep the size of the uneducated in abeyance - whether in construction or politics.

My point is that, instead of thinking in terms of the "stimulus package" with its "multiplier effect" where there is none, it may not be too late for us and if possible the government to come up with a development plan to raise the value-added of the economic activities of the country.

This must work through the education system, giving room for education to be translated into innovative ideas and hopefully commercially-viable ideas, and a stage for the display and execution of these ideas. I am of course talking about industrial ideas - but I am also thinking of agricultural ideas as well as ideas in the services industry - which must include the arts - music, art, drama.

I think the idea of developing areas in other places of the nation outside the Klang Valley is also a very good way of spreading development nationwide. This will create jobs in their neigbourhood instead of getting job seekers to leave their families. It is also a good chance to allow those outside the Klang Valley to make some money, instead of concentrating the wealth of the nation in the hands of a few in the Klang Valley.

Confidence

Although Keynes talked a great length on the effect of confidence on investment, it was in the negative sense - that the loss of confidence has caught investors to run away and keep cash (if at home) and I presume invest abroad (if they have a chance to take their money out).

Let me elaborate the point on confidence in the Malaysian case.

For the moment, confidence is generated by the immediate economic prospect. In recent past, confidence came from government projects. In recent months, confidence jumped out of the window because of the US financial meltdown. Coming up with a modest package of government spending is not likely to have a stimulating effect - for the economy or anyone.

What is important for the country - if the economy is to pick and grow consistently in the coming 20 to 30 years - is for the people to have confidence. Confidence, in this case, comes from credibility of policy or a clear direction for the future (not the V2020 type). We see political troubles ahead because of ideology. We see more political troubles ahead because of the economy.

It has been asked why some countries with high taxes can have high economic growth? The answer: confidence. The high taxes are used to fund a social safety net so that all citizens know they will be taken care of when they are sick or old, so that they are willing to plough back what they earn into the system, after having spent all that they want to enjoy the life that they imagine.

Where does the system come from? Not from migrant workers; it comes from the work of every citizen in the various segments of the society in which they live.

It is therefore against the grain of nation-building to be pitching one group against another, to be excluding any group from the productive workforce, to be inadvertently sabotaging the national system by filling in important positions with wrong skills.

Friday, December 5, 2008

Keynesian Irrelevance I: Banks

There are two major problems in the world economy today:
1. Collapse of banks
2. Collapse of the economy.

In Keynes' General Theory, banking collapse is ignored. The focus is purely on the role of expectations on money demand and investment - in this sense: as uncertainty increases, people keep cash and forgo investment - even if interest rates are lowered to near zero, because the objective of people is to preserve capital value (don't lose money) rather than seek out the higher return (as investors would do).

How do banks collapse? Banks collapse when their bad loans are greater than their capital and reserves. Banking is a very tricky business which requires one to understand simple arithmatic.

Banks expose themselves fully in return for a fraction. If the rate of interest is 10%, a bank lends RM100 to earn RM10 - which means that if there is just a single default (say, RM100), then the bank has to lend out 10 good loans (with no default) earning RM10X10 to cover the default. If the rate of interest is 5%, then the cover is 20 good loans (RM100X20) to earn (RM5X20) to cover the RM100 default. So, if banks are earning a net margin of only 1% (lending rate minus cost of funds minus cost of operations), then we are talking about a cover of 100 times - our terminology for saying that we need 100 good loans to cover 1 bad loan of the same size.

Banks therefore cannot afford to have default. It is a basic banking rule that, if the borrower does not have a good credit rating, don't lend; a higher rate of interest cannot do any justice to lending to bad borrowers. (I lifted this remark from an old banking handbook I read long ago from an old timer who wrote the manual for the Bank of America, if I remember.)

Now, if banks are consciously going after bad borrowers, i.e. sub-prime customers, then they are really looking for trouble. I don't think the bankers and their regulators, especially in the US under Greenspan, understand that.

Now, if banks are lending out 400 times this capital and reserves, then they are really in big trouble. In other words, they have RM1 in capital and reserves for every RM400 they lend out. If they have a default of RM1, they are in trouble. That RM1 default is only 0.25% of their total loans. In other words, at loans 400 times the capital and reserve, they can only afford an NPL (non-performing loan or bad loan) ratio of only 0.25%.

Of course, they are relying on the return of the remaining RM399 to pull through, especially on the expecteed larger rate of return - which simply means higher risks. The scene is thus set for banking collapse.

Using our earlier example of a 5% net return (being generous), we are saying that a RM1 default requires RM20 good loans to cover. So the breakeven NPL ratio is 4.76%, very close to the net rate of return. If the net rate of return is 1%, then the breakeven NPL ratio is 1% from loans.

If we add in the capital and reserves for cover (formally called the capital-adequacy ratio), then the breakeven NPL ratio for a bank is the sum of (i) net rate of return (say, 2%) and (ii) the capital-adequacy ratio (say, 10%). I think you can do your own sums for individual banks.

Proviso: The NPL ratio is a tricky thing. In a booming economy, the NPL ratio is small; in a bad economy, the NPL ratio is high. Why?

Your answer is wrong - that the amount of bad loans increases in a bad economy. Half of the correct answer is that the amount of bad loans increases under all circumstances - during both good and bad times.

The full correct answer is that, in a booming economy, banks are happily giving out loans such that the amount of new loans is larger than the increase in bad loans. In a bad economy like now, bad loans are rising ("I see bad loans arising") while new loans are hard to come by or, if the banks are cash strapped, they may recall the good loans and shrink their loan base. (The latter is called a credit crunch.)

Bad loans don't come, they pour.

Policy Responses

The bailout of banks and financial institutions is only one part of the rescue.

Do you save banks that do not know how to do banking? The last time I was asked by the Board of Directors of a bank to study the major cause of bad loans, my answer was that loan growth was excessive.

Now, why would banks be reckless in giving out loans. Because the deposits are not theirs. Half the answer. The other half (in light of a swinging stock market) is that the CEO's renumeration is tied to his ESOS which depends on the share price to make him an instant multi-millionaire. The only for a bank to push the share price is to register rapid loan growth which is good for earnings as well as for the low NPL ratio and the capital and reserves.

The real test of the strength of a bank is during bad times - to see how little their loan book is bad.

Not only that, whether during trying times, the bank understands the economics and the economic structure and what's happening in the world economy and how new opportunities can be tapped for future growth.

A bank that has relied on bad lending policy such as by lending to shares and real estate and consumers will not know what to do during trying times. Its CEO just bails out

The future of a nation is really dependent on the foresight of its bankers (and dare I say central bankers).

The banker must be able to see like an entrepreneur (but without being greedy himself) and works with the businessman or corporation to go for new opportunities. It is the support a good bank to a good customer that is the backbone of a vibrant economy. If a country has bad bankers and bad businessmen, then the country in for a perpetual series of bailouts in the name of pump-priming or whatever the fancy names that Keynes has invented.

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

The Irrelevance of Keynes

Before Keynes, we didn't know that the slump was caused first by the bank collapse and then the inadequacy of aggregate demand. Now we know, thanks to Keynes and his disciple, Milton Friedman (yes, of course, after all, he uttered "We're all Keynesians now!"). So what went wrong today, and how can Keynes be relevant today if despite his advice, we are still in the same type of slump?

I think the problem is bigger than managing aggregate demand and the money supply. We may have all been taught wrongly by our economic professors - who after all are like "nasi lemak" sellers in a row, selling homogeneous products except for the power of the sambal.

Keynes was a liberal in as much as Churchill was, and his great concern was that the prevailing model of democracy of the Western World may be lost to the new Russian order. Can the free economy be discarded for the command economy? As the free world fell into a slump, he was concerned that it would lead to a political change and he responded with the General Theory which argued that the government must add demand to the economy to keep it up, at a time when the UK Treasury was quite happy to let the economy adjust itself properly despite the huge unemployment.

The Classical economist, Keynes argued, has got the economic story wrong. While it is true that the market is an integral component of a modern economy, the market does not operate according to theory initially envisaged - where if the price goes up, demand is reduced, when the price falls, demand increases; and all is well. All has not been well, as we can see today by the effect of the fuel price in recent months and the catastrophic effect that it has caused the economy, despite the current decline in the oil price. I think the point about the market being not symmetrical has been well understood, though not necessarily by policymakers. It would therefore appear that counter-cyclical policy is the way to go - and with the revivial of Bretton Woods (another Keyensian creature) - if Keynes is still relevant. But Keynes is not relevant anymore.

The rise of China economy has shown the world that the market mechanism is not the monopoly of democracy. This puts Adam Smith more at risk than Keynes.

Aggregate demand cannot be the issue today, as the very loose monetary policy of Greenspan has shown. The collapse of the world economy today is not that there is not sufficient money stock in the system or that there is not enough aggregate demand but the contrary - there is too much money printed and incredible amount of aggregate demand as evidenced by the huge budgetary deficit of governments around the world. The ordinary person is simply exhausted from too much consumption and investment. This Keynesian proposition is therefore wrong.

If we observe where the economic failure is, in 1930s or even today, it is the collapse of asset prices - of stocks and real estate.

So the real problem could be that the sustained asset inflation due to prolonged printing of money has created a false sense of security for many people who thought they have been set up for a comfortable retirement. The bursting of the asset bubble has made naught their dream and now they do not know what to do with having practicised a proper profession for some time - apart from punting in the stock and property markets.

The reason for stock market earnings not being taxed is that it is considered by economists not to represent earnings in the proper sense - merely the transfer of payment from the loser in the punt to the winner in the punt. Now, I think that, since the government is invariably caught with having to rescue the stock market with it collapse, we should tax stock market earnings and put that tax in a sinking fund (in cash, please, not stocks). Governments should not use taxpayers' money to prop up share prices.

The tendency for the monetary economy to keep collapsing comes from the tendency of the banking system to lend to create collateral assets such as shares and real estate. This gives rise to a virtuous cycle (which gives huge payouts to bank CEOs) which then collapses into a vicious cycle once banks exhausted their avenues for lending. The pay of bank CEOs should not be tied to bank share prices - because it rewards the building of the foundation for future economic disaster.

I disagree that Keynesian countercyclical policy should be for stabilisation purposes -because it assumes that the economic structure is still good and therefore runs the risk of propping up the inefficient and problem sectors. The economy could have collapsed, as of now, because of a change in the structure of the economy.

The collapse of the Japan economy in the 1980s was due to rise of IT in the US, likewise, the collapse of the US economy is the result of the rise of China.

The problem of the Malaysia economy today is the result of the temporary rise of FDIs (as a result of the collapse of the Japan economy in the 1980s) which led the government to embark on infrastructure expansion (which is now in a glut) and accentuated by the rise of China (investment outflows). To continue to build mega projects would be to prop up construction firms at the expense of the knowledge-building industries. Industrial investment should drive infrastructure development.

The focus on stabilisation policy may have been done in the past at the expense of the need for a long term strategy for national economic supremacy. Has Keynes done more harm than good in Malaysia?

National economic supremacy should be based on education and knowledge, the application of skills and the practice of diligence - founded on a national economic system with a strong social safety net especially for old age.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Illusion of Being Wealthy

Most, if not all, of us must be quite sick and tired of life that we really want to be very wealthy - so wealthy that we would rather not be doing anything.

Nowadays, in the present era where the stock market is the only casino in town open to all and sundry to punt, I see well-dressed men and women - or rather well-dressed couples - idling around shopping malls with the downtrodden - one having bought everything and has nothing to buy and the other not buying because no money.

What do we get in a world where everybody is wealthy?

Nothing, because nobody is working.

The streets would be strewn with cash and nobody wants it because each would have more than the other - so much that there is no point keeping physical cash - easier just to register it as a computer number.

The point about the idea of being wealthy is it quite an evil thought - that there is value in being wealthy only because others are poor. Then the poor buggers will have to slog just to keep alive - in order to toil.

The ancient Greeks and Romans were at least honest. Aristotle argued the need for slaves so that noblemen could lead noble lives. The blacks in the US fought for the right to be free. They are no different from the many immigrant workers we get in countries like Malaysia where they worked their full ten hours a day for the lowest pay in the region.

I celebrate work. But to imagine that we could amass durable items of value so that we would entice the poor to labour according to our fancy is to place the weight of our rightful labour on the shoulders of the unfortunate.

In the extreme, when everybody does not work, then those who have money will want to buy the services of the poor. If the poor are uneducated and unable to fend for themselves, then the only thing they will do is to prostitute themselves - in the truest sense of the world. It is not a wonder that it is the oldest profession - born out of the inert desire of people - to propagate the genes. Surprisingly, both parties are happy - although it may not be sustaining given diminishing returns.

The most sustaining model of life, in my mind, is man or woman roaming free in nature - surviving on whatever little can be found. There is nothing wrong with this model - it must have been around for many hundred thousands of years. In the last two or three hundred years, our incomplete understanding of technology has produced "goods" without offsetting them with the "bads." The wealthy of current generations are creating poverty in future generations.

It may be time for the educated and intelligent to be cultivated and wise and share the fruits of their knowledge with the more unfortunate. This can be done by stopping dreaming about being wealthy (because it is an absurd concept) and start taking care of oneself, one's family and one's neighbours.

It is pitiful to see how the powerful holds out to the desolute with promises of wealth which the powerful cannot keep. (Not surprising that lies and broken promises are a by-product of democracy.)

There is wisdom in the people not listening to politicians. There is also wisdom in politicians not listening to industrialists. There is also wisdom in industrialists not listening to scientists and technologists.

But there is wisdom in children listening to their mothers or, if not, their fathers. Then the world could be a richer place.